1973 - Battle of the Albums Grand Final

[Toy Revolver]

imma rank da pf albums

15) division
14) reason
13) clouds
12) endless river
11) wish you were here
10) moon
9) piper
8 ) secrets
7) more
6) atom heart mother
5) meddle
4) wall
3) final cut
2) ummagumma
1) animals

[Guybrush]

DSOTM is wonderful. There are albums I like more, but not that many if I'm honest. The aforementioned Close to the Edge is one of them.

[Toy Revolver]

DSOTM is wonderful. There are albums I like more, but not that many if I'm honest. The aforementioned Close to the Edge is one of them.

i like Close to the Edge quite a bit more - it's probably my favorite prog album tbh

[Lexi Darling]

i like Close to the Edge quite a bit more - it's probably my favorite prog album tbh

It's my favorite prog album for sure and in the running for my favorite album of all time period.

[Guybrush]

CttE is probably my all-time favorite prog album too so that makes what.. four of us with Comus?

I don't really listen to CttE or DSotM these days, though I might just have to get back into PF as it's been a while.

[Comus]

Pipers is utter shit in comparison

dafuq?

Don't get me wrong, great album, just not compared to WYWH, Animals and DSotM.

[Guybrush]

Mentioned this elsewhere, but my first meeting with DSotM was actually the Pulse live album disc 2 where they play through the entirety of DSotM.

It's pretty great, so check that out if you haven't already

Also the dub side of the moon tribute album was kinda fun.