Britpop Bands - rank and discuss

[jimmy jazz]

Oasis defo don't have effortless cool. Liam forces it as well as his working classness.

The walk 
The sunglasses 
The overkill of swearing 
The football fandom

Regarding this post from Lisna:

I once saw their big hits dismissed as "pub singalongs", and perhaps that's why they have fallen from popularity since their '90s heydays.

I don't think they have fallen from popularity. They're just as popular now if not more so. They haven't released anything in twenty years but people younger than me gravitate toward them. I've said this before but they're genuinely held in the same regard as the Beatles, Pink Floyd, Led Zep, Stones etc by a particular type of person. It's really strange. As I said, think it's partly to do with the BBC and what they push. You don't have to dig deep to find their music, it's just there.

[SGR]

Oasis defo don't have effortless cool. Liam forces it as well as his working classness.

The walk 
The sunglasses 
The overkill of swearing 
The football fandom

I very rarely got the sense that they were putting on a front or forcing an image. I feel like the closest they came to that is when they leaned too deeply into the Beatles (e.g. "Don't Look Back in Anger", "Champagne Supernova", "All Around the World"). Still, I do think that came from a genuine love for The Beatles. I think it's sort of like you said, they're a couple of knobheads - but it's the fact that they embrace it that makes them come off as authentic (similar thing with Mark E. Smith, total asshole, but he embraced it and didn't shy away from it that made it oddly endearing). They behave practically the same way today (in interviews, f.ex) as they did in 1996, though likely with a little less inebriation. I've got a very sophomoric sense of humor too, so the humor of the Gallagher brothers is right up my alley. 

[jimmy jazz]

Noel less so. Liam definitely does though.

[Marie Monday]

Suede hasn't gotten much love here, and I'm not that high on their first record - but their follow-up record, Dog Man Star, is a very good record.

yeah was actually listening to it yesterday and thinking maybe I'm doing them an injustice not voting for them (I like them, Pulp and Blur about equally anyway but there's only so many bands you can vote for). At least, I listen to dog man star more often than anything by those other bands. The real injustice is Super Furry Animals being rated so low though, even though I don't consider them britpop. By far the best band in this thread

[Marie Monday]

ps Super Furry Animals being much better than the other bands here is also why they shouldn't be classified as britpop xoxo